Unfortunately for these people, there’s a simple, but quite larger issue with their logic: it’s wrong.
A new study from political scientists Laura Royden and Eitan Hersh thoroughly debunks the myth that American conservatives are less likely to hold anti-semitic beliefs than those on the left. In fact, the study finds that among the largest ways to determine if a person is an anti-semite – believing that Jews are loyal to Israel, defending boycotting Jewish businesses, and saying that Jews have too much power – it’s conservatives that display the most anti-Jewish bias. In fact, the more conservative a person is, the likelier they are to have anti-semitic beliefs.
I could say that these results don’t shock me at all, but I’d be lying. I’ve always agreed that there is at least some level of anti-Jewish sentiment behind elements of the far-left, including Ilhan Omar’s tweets that flirted with the corrupt Jew stereotype, and a growing sense among American far-left activists that Israel itself should be destroyed. My expectation – just as the authors’ were – was that anti-semitism would be somewhat like a horseshoe: high on the far-left and far-right, and low in the center. But instead, the most left-wing people are the least anti-semitic group in America.
Understanding the data is a lot easier when you’re aware of the other political science literature on what motivates the left and right. Though the conventional wisdom is that people adopt the political identities that match their policy beliefs, (pro-lifers are conservatives, pro-choicers are liberals) it’s more accurate to say that people’s broader political identities come from their personalities. For example, one of the best predictors of political ideology is “openness to experience.” The phrase is one of the “Big Five” personality traits, and is a measure of how comfortable a person is with diverse, new experiences. Unsurprisingly, people who have high openness to experience tend to be very liberal, and people low in openness to experience tend to be conservative.
Now, obviously, being low in “openness to experience” doesn’t automatically mean a person should be cast off as a bigot. However, there is strong evidence that people who are low in openness to experience are likelier to be raciallybigoted. It makes sense that people most opposed to racial and cultural diversity tend to be the most anti-semitic.
This also means that media coverage of left-wing anti-semitism should always address these points. There’s no doubt that there is a problem of anti-semitism on certain elements of the left. And those elements should be called out rigorously as there’s no excuse for bigotry anywhere. However, saying that those elements on the left are more prone to anti-Jewish bigotry than those on the right is just wrong. It may feel correct. But as Ben Shapiro would say, “Facts don’t care about your feelings.”